Skip to main content

Full text of "A Statistical Strategy for the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect's Cluster Data"

See other formats

A Statistical Strategy for the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effects Cluster 


Jounghun Lee 

Department of Physics, University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan 

O ■ lee@utap . phys . s . u-tokyo 


We present a statistical strategy for the efficient determination of the clus- 
ter luminosity function from the interferometric Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effects 
cluster data. To determine the cluster luminosity function from the noise con- 
00 ' taminated SZ map, we first define the zeroth-order cluster luminosity function 

as difference between the measured peak number density of the SZ map and the 
lO ' mean number density of noise. Then we demonstrate that the noise contamina- 

^ 1 tion effects can be removed by the stabilized deconvolution of the zeroth-order 

cluster luminosity function with the one-dimensional Gaussian distribution. We 
test this analysis technique against Monte-Carlo simulations, and find that it 
works quite well especially in the medium amplitude range where the conven- 
tional cluster selection method based on the threshold cut-off usually fails. 


Subject headings: galaxies: clusters: general — methods: statistical 


Galaxy clusters are the biggest bound objects of the universe. Being rare and formed rel- 
atively late, the abundance of galaxy clusters depends sensitively on the background cosmol- 
ogy (Barbosa et al. 1996; Henry 1997; Bahcall & Fan 1998; Viana & Liddle 1999; Borgani et al. 1999; 
Fan & Chiueh 2001; Grego et al. 2001; Molnar et al. 2002). To find as many galaxy clusters 
as possible and to investigate the evolution of their abundance have thus become two of the 
most challenging tasks of the current observational cosmology. The cluster survey is cat- 
egorized by the observing waveband as the X-ray, the optical, and the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich 
effect. In the past the X-ray or the optical surveys were favored due to their high rate 
of detecting clusters and relatively low-costs. However, thanks to recent development in 
technology, the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect is currently spotlighted as a powerful cosmological 


probe (Carlstrom et al. 1996; White et al. 1999; Holder et al. 2000; Lo et al. 2000) that can 
provide a statistically unbiased sample of clusters unlike the X-ray and the optical surveys. 

The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect represents the change in brightness of the cosmic 
microwave background (CMB) radiation caused by the interaction of the CMB photons with 
the ionized intra-cluster gas (Sunyaev & Zel'dovich 1972). The underlying physics of the SZ 
effect is the inverse Compton scattering: free electrons of the hot intra-cluster gas scatter 
off the CMB photons as they pass through the galaxy clusters, which results in the shift of 
the CMB photon frequency and a corresponding change in its radiation energy. Depending 
on whether the scattering of the CMB photons was by the random or systematic motions 
of the electrons, the SZ effect is called thermal or kinetic respectively. Here we focus on 
the thermal SZ effect since its contribution is order of magnitude stronger than the kinetic 
counterpart (Springel et al. 2001; Zhang et al. 2002). 

The SZ effects (A//) observed at a given frequency (/) at a given position 9 on the sky 
depend on the electron number density {n e ) and temperature (T e ) within the galaxy clusters 
that the CMB photons have encountered all along the path: 

AI f (9) = -2#^§ / n e (W)T e (W)dl = -2g f y(9), (1) 

with the integral taken along the CMB path in the line-of-sight direction (9 = 9/\9\). Here y 
is the cluster Comptonization parameter, and Qf is the frequency-dependent spectral shape 
factor. Note that the SZ effects are spatially localized with the associated clusters along the 
line of sight, unlike the primordial CMB fluctuations. 

Equation (1) implies that the amplitude of the SZ effects observed in a narrow frequency 
band with almost fixed gf can be quantified by the ^/-parameter. Provided that noise were 
absent in the SZ map, clusters could be counted as local maxima of y. In practice, however, 
noise always dominate the SZ map. A critical issue is how to eliminate the dominant noise- 
contamination effects. A common observational practice to identify true signals from the 
noise-contaminated field is to select only such peaks with amplitudes above some threshold 
(usually several times the noise standard deviation). Using this technique, however, one 
can select only high-amplitude signals for a given observational integration time. In order 
to increase the signal to noise ratio, one has to decrease the noise level by increasing the 
integration time, which is proportional only to the square of the the noise level. 

Considering the usual high-costs of the SZ experiments, this conventional technique of 
signal selection is too inefficient to apply to the SZ cluster data . One may wish to find 
a more efficient statistical strategy that can allow us to determine the cluster luminosity 
function as quickly and accurately as possible. Powerful new generations of SZ instruments 

- 3- 

such as AMiBA (Array for Microwave Background Anisotropy, see Lo et al. 2001) are already 
in the pipeline. Expecting plenty of cluster data coming out in a few years, it is quite urgent 
in fact to develop such statistical strategies now. 

In this Letter we develop a statistical strategy for the efficient determination of the 
cluster luminosity function, especially from interferometric SZ surveys using AMiBA as our 
model experiment. 


The SZ cluster luminosity function, n c i(y), is defined as the number density of galaxy 
clusters with the associated cluster Compton parameter in the range of [y,y + dy}. Its 
cumulative function, N c i(> y) = f n c i(y')dy', is connected to the cluster mass function 
(see eq.[7] in Barbosa et al. 1996), and thus can be used in principle as a cosmological 
discriminator (Holder et al. 2000; Fan & Chiueh 2001; Diego et al. 2002; Grego et al. 2001; 
Molnar et al. 2002; Benson et al. 2002). In practice, the direct conversion of the cluster 
luminosity function into the cluster mass function is fraught with the difficulties related to 
the rather large scatter in the correlation between cluster mass and the SZ effect strength 
(e.g., see Metzler 2002). 

Anyway, our goal here is to find an efficient way to find n c i(y) from the observed SZ map 
that is expected to be significantly contaminated by noise. There are two different sources 
of noise: instrumental noise and primordial CMB fluctuations. The primordial fluctuations, 
however, turned out to be negligible in interferometric SZ cluster surveys (Zhang et al. 2002). 
In the following analysis, we concentrate on instrumental noise only. 

Our model experiment, AMiBA, as an interferometric SZ survey, will employ the drift- 
scan method to optimize the observations. For the detailed description of AMiBA and 
the drift-scan method, see Lo et al. (2000) and Pen et al. (2002) respectively. Among 
many advantages of the drift-scan method, it makes noise-analysis tractable: in a SZ map 
measured from the drift-scanned CMB sky, noise is Gaussian white. Therefore, a total 
SZ map measured by AMiBA will be a combination of non-Gaussian cluster sources with 
Gaussian white. In the following two subsections, we simulate a total SZ map by means of 
the Monte-Carlo method, and reconstruct the cluster luminosity function by eliminating the 
noise contamination effects from the SZ map. 


2.1. Monte-Carlo Simulations of Drift-Scan SZ Maps 

We have constructed a random field on a 2048 2 mesh in a periodic box of linear size 1 
deg using the Monte-Carlo method, in such a way that the random field possesses the main 
statistical properties of a cleaned SZ map expected from AMiBA drift-scan survey over a 
unit area per a unit hour, assuming the flat-sky approximation. 

By a cleaned SZ map, we mean the SZ map smoothed by a optimal filter: In Fourier 
u-space (u: the Fourier counterpart of 9, u = |u|), the optimal filter for AMiBA drift-scan 
observations is given (Pen et al. 2002) as W c (u) = W F (u)W N (u), where W F (u) and W N (u) 
are the cluster intrinsic shape and the natural beam respectively. We use W F (u) = ^ and 

approximate Wjy(u) as Wn{u) ~ exp ^— — |^ — exp ^— — where the two angular scales, 
9a and 9b, represent the size of the natural and primary beam respectively, related to each 
other by |^ = | (Pen 2002, private communications). We first constructed a Gaussian 
random field with the white noise power spectrum and convolved it by Wc(u), and rescaled 
the field by its rms fluctuations, <j\ = J \Wc(u)\ 2 d 2 u. 

Second, we simulated the cluster sources by generating a sparse set of two dimensional 
Gaussian functions of which peak locations and amplitudes were chosen randomly. Zhang 
et al. (2002) showed that the optimal scan rate for the purpose of AMiBA cluster search is 
around 150 hours per square degree, which could find 1 cluster every 8 hours. Thus, the 
total number of the cluster sources was set to be 20, with the expectation that the number 
of clusters per square degree from the AMiBA cluster search would be around the same 
number. We locate the cluster sources in the two-dimensional map deliberately so that they 
are not overlapping one another. The size of each cluster source, i.e., the length scale of each 
Gaussian function was chosen to be twice the pixel size, which is consistent with the expected 
AMiBA drift-scan map. The randomly chosen amplitudes of the cluster sources were in the 
range of [0, 5<7 ] where we would like to reconstruct the cluster luminosity function from the 
noise-contaminated map. The cluster amplitudes were chosen to be distributed exponentially, 
mimicking the real cluster distribution in this range (Zhang et al. 2002). 

Finally, we obtained a simulated SZ map by combining the Gaussian noise field with 
the cluster sources. Then we identified the local maxima of the total field by selecting 
those pixels whose amplitudes exceed the amplitudes of their 8 closest-neighboring points, 
and count the number density of the total SZ map, n sz (v), as a function of the rescaled 
amplitude, v = y/cro- 

- 5 - 

2.2. Deconvolution Method 

If there were no clusters, the measured SZ map would be just a map of Gaussian 
noise, whose mean number density of local maxima, n g (u), is analytically derived to be 
(Longuet-Higgins 1957; Bond & Efstathiou 1987): 

f \ 1 D -2 -4 f°r 2 M -J 1i exp[-|( 3 ;-7^) 2 /(l-7 2 )] ^ (t) . 

%H = 7^^ e 2 y o [* + e -i] — [27r (i- 7 2)]i/2 — ( 2 ) 

Here of = / | 2 w 2i gPu for our noise spectrum, and i?* = y/2(a 1 /a 2 ), 7 = 

o" 2 /(o"oO"2)- 

The difference between the peak number density of the total SZ map and equation 
(2) provides a zeroth-order approximation to the cluster luminosity function: n^\u) = 
n sz (v) — n g {y). At high z/-tail {y 1) where the mean number density of noise peaks drops 
practically to zero, n sz (v) ~ n^{y) « n c i(v). At low-z/ range (0 < v < 2) where Gaussian 
noise strongly dominates, n sz (u) w n 9 (z/) and n£\u) measures just Poissonian noise scatter 
around equation (2). 

The intriguing section is at the medium- v range [y ~ 3), where n^(z/) includes not only 
the noise-scatter but also the noise-contaminated cluster peaks to a non-negligible degree. 
With the conventional cluster selection procedure based on the amplitude cut-off, the number 
density of cluster peaks in this intermediate range cannot be determined since the peaks in 
this range are all disregarded as noise. Thus, it is this medium-amplitude section where one 
needs a better analysis technique to find the number density. 

Noise contaminates the cluster number density by changing its amplitude. Let x measure 
the noise-contamination effects on the peak amplitude such that v = is + x where uq and 
v are the real and contaminated amplitude of a cluster peak respectively. For a Gaussian 
noise, x can be assumed to be a Gaussian variable. Now, the probability distribution of v 
can be written as a convolution of the probability distributions of i>q and x. In terms of the 
number density, one can say 

yytot p 

n{ $Hy) = lh P{x)n d {v - x)dx, (3) 

sz J 


where p(x) = -^e - ^" and iV^f and iV^ ot are the total number of peaks of the SZ map and 
that of real clusters respectively. 

Equation (3) implies that the cluster luminosity function, n c i(u), can be found by the 
deconvolution of the n^\u) and p(x). In theory, the deconvolution of n^\u) and p(x) could 
be easily conducted : just dividing the Fourier transform of n$ (v) by that of p(x), performing 

- 6- 

its inverse Fourier transformation. In practice, however, the deconvolution process itself 
is very unstable (Press et al. 1992). To make the deconvolution stable and optimize the 
estimation of n c i(u), we apply a Wiener filter, say, Wp(v), to n^\u). 

Let P- and P + be the real and corrupted power spectrum of n^\u) respectively, then 
the Wiener filter in the Fourier z/ fc -space [y k : the Fourier counter part of v) can be written 
as Wp(uk) = p~[^| ■ O ne can easily see that Wp(u k ) ps 1 where the error is negligible, and 
Wp(vk) ~ where the error is dominant. Unfortunately, we cannot determine the exact func- 
tional form of Wp{vk) since the only available quantity to us is P + (z/&). Nevertheless, since 
the Wiener filter works in the least-square sense (Press et al. 1992), even a fairly reasonable 
approximation to Wp(uk) can make it work quite well. Figure 1 plots P + (vk), showing there 
is a sharp boundary between the noise-dominant and negligible sections where P + (uk) has 
two distinct behaviors. Finding a turning point, v k0 , by eye, we approximated the Wiener 
filter by a step function such that Wp{v k ) = 0(\vk\ < i^o), given the asymptotic behaviors 
oiW P (y h ). 

Here is our recipe for the determination of the cluster luminosity function from the 
total SZ map: Construct n^\u) on a one-dimensional discrete grid by counting the peak 
number density of the total SZ map and subtracting equation (3) from it. Calculate its 
power spectrum, P + {y k ), by measuring the mean square amplitude of its Fourier transform. 
Plot P + (vk) to find the turning-point, v k o- Approximate Wp{y k ) as a step-function such 
that Wp(vk) = 0(|z/fc| < z/fco)- Convolve n^\u) by Wp(u k ) and deconvolve it by the one- 
dimensional Gaussian distribution, p(x). 

In the upper panel of Figure 2, we show the cumulative cluster luminosity function N c i(> 
v) (solid line) reconstructed from the SZ map with the above recipe and compare it with the 
real distribution (square dots). We also plot the cumulative peak number density of the total 
SZ map (long-dashed line), the cumulative noise mean number density (dashed line), and 
the cumulative zeroth-order cluster luminosity function (dotted line) for comparison. Figure 
2 reveals that the reconstructed cluster luminosity function is indeed in good agreement with 
the real distribution, especially in the medium range of 2 < v < 4. Note also that in the 
low-f section {y < 1) noise dominates the SZ peaks while in the high-z/ tail {y > 4) the total 
SZ peaks are mainly the cluster peaks as expected. 

When determining n c /(z/), the total number of cluster peaks, A^ ot , are assumed to be 
given as priors. In case that iV^ ot is not available, we can still determine the probability 
density distribution of cluster peaks, P c i(> v) = N d (> ^/N^. The lower panel of Figure 
2 plots the cumulative probability density distributions that can be determined using our 
analysis technique without any prior. Again, the real and the reconstructed distributions 
agree with each other quite well. 


We tested our technique against different realizations of the SZ maps by varying the 
total number of cluster peaks and distribution shapes, and found it quite robust. 


We have developed a useful analysis technique to determine the cluster luminosity func- 
tion efficiently, using AMiBA, a drift-scan interferometric SZ survey, as a model experiment. 
We have simulated a total SZ map using the Monte-Carlo method, and counted the peak 
number density from it. The total SZ map is constructed by combining a Gaussian noise 
field with cluster sources. We noted that the peak number density of the SZ map at medium 
peak amplitude range has non-negligible contributions from the cluster peaks with noise- 
contamination effects included. 

To determine the cluster number density, i.e., the cluster luminosity function, first we 
have measured the zeroth-order cluster luminosity function by subtracting the available 
mean noise number density from the peak number density of the total SZ map. We have 
quantified the noise-contamination effects included in the zeroth-order approximation by a 
single Gaussian variable, and found that the cluster luminosity function can be expressed 
as the deconvolution of the zeroth-order approximation by the one-dimensional Gaussian 

We have stabilized the deconvolution process by convolving the zeroth-order approxi- 
mation with a Wiener filter. The approximate functional form of the Wiener filter has been 
determined from the information of the power spectrum of the zeroth-order approximation. 
Finally by deconvolving the Wiener-filtered zeroth-order approximation of the cluster lumi- 
nosity function we have determined the cluster luminosity function from the simulated SZ 
map. We have compared the reconstructed (cumulative) cluster luminosity function with 
the real one, and found good agreements between them, especially in the medium amplitude 
range where the conventional technique fails. 

The consequence of the statistical strategy presented here is that it can allow us to 
find the cumulative distribution of the sources even when the number of the sources occupy 
only small fraction of the total number of maximum peaks. We also expect this statistical 
strategy to be applied to the construction of the cluster mass function in weak gravitational 
lensing analysis. 

However, it is worth noting that the measurement accuracy of the cluster luminosity 
function may be improved on by improving the approximation accuracy of the Winer filter, 
and it is also worth noting that although our technique determines the cluster number 

- 8- 

density efficiently but it cannot select the cluster peaks from the SZ map. Furthermore, to 
examine the usefulness of our analysis technique in real practice, testing it against real SZ 
hydrodynamic simulations will be necessary. Our future work is in this direction. 

We thank U. L. Pen for many helpful discussions on drift-scan method, and K. Yoshikawa 
for useful comments. This work was supported by the research grants of the JSPS fellowship 

- 9- 


Bahcall, N., k Fan, X. 1998, ApJ, 504, 1 

Barbosa, D. Bartlett, J. G., Blanchard, A., k Oukbir, J. 1996, A&A, 314, 13 
Benson, A. J., Reichardt, C, k Kamionkowski, M. 2002, MNRAS, 331, 71 
Bond, J. R., k Efstathious, G. 1987, MNRAS,226, 655 
Borgani, S., Rosati, P., Tozzi, P., k Colin, N. 1999, ApJ, 517, 40 
Carlstrom, J. E., Joy, M., k Grego L. 1996, ApJ, 456, 75 

Diego, J. M., Martinez-Gonzalev, E., Sanz, j£ L., Benitez, N., J. Silk 2002, MNRAS, 331, 

Fan, Z., k Chiueh, T. 2001, ApJ, 550, 547 

Grego, L., Carlstrom, J. E., Reese, E. D., Holder, G. P., Holzapfel, W. L., Joy, M. K., Mohr, 
J. J., k Patel, S. 2001, 552, 2 

Henry, J. P. 1997, ApJ, 489, LI 

Holder, G. P., Mohr,J. J., Carlstrom, J. E., Evrard, A. E., k Leitch, E. M. 2000, ApJ, 544, 

Lo, K. H., Chiueh, T. H., Martin, R. N., Ng, K. W., Liang, H., Pen, U. L, k Ma, C. P. 2000, 
preprint (astro-ph/0012282) 

Longuet-Higgins, M. S. 1957, Phil Trans Roy Soc London A, 249, 321 

Metzler, C. A. 2002, preprint (astro-ph/9812295) 

Molnar, S. M., birkinshaw, M.,& Mushotzky, R. F. 2002, ApJ, 570, 1 

Pen, U. L., Ng, K. W., Kesteven, M. J., k Sault, B. 2002, preprint 

Press, W. H., Teukolsky, S. A., Vetterling, W. T., k Flannery, B. P. 1992, Numerical Recipes 
in Fortran (Univ. of Cambridge: New York) 

Springel, V., White, M., Hernquist, L. 2001, ApJ, 549, 681 

Sunyaev, R. A., k Zel'dovich, Y. B. 1972, Comm. Astrophys. Sp. Phys., 4, 173 

Viana, P. T. P., k Liddle, A. R. 1999, 303, 535 

White, M., Carlstrom, J. E., Dragovan, M., & Holzapfel, W. L. 1999, ApJ, 514, 12 
Zhang, P., Pen, U. L., & Wang, B. 2002, preprint (astro-ph/0201375) 

This preprint was prepared with the AAS IATgX macros v5.0. 

- 11 - 

Fig. 1. — The power spectrum of the SZ map. The dashed line indicates the location of the 
turning point. 

- 12 - 

t — i — i — r 

~\ — r 

~\ — r 


t — i — r 



total SZ 


total SZ 
X\ . real clusters 

- noise : 

I I I 

Fig. 2. — Upper.The cumulative number density of local maxima as a function of the rescaled 
amplitude, v. The total number of cluster peaks (iV* z ot ) are assumed to be given as a prior. 
iV^ ot = 20 in this figure. Lower. The cumulative probability distribution of local maxima 
as a function of the rescaled amplitude. Unlike the number density, the cluster probability 
distribution can be reconstructed without any prior.