that's why barbara hale and i have a hard time planning our budgets for additional resources. we know what we have now and as kathleen said we're fully expected to keep going where we are now, but that additionality is tough and it's tough no know how much and when. whether it's legislative or not, the voice of this body needs to be heard at the california public utilities commission. i mean if you look at what's going on internationally now, there's tremendous understanding that green house gas production emissions happen at the city level and we are fully equiped to make those happen if we have the freedom to do it right and that's the message we need to deliver to the california public utilities commission who i think, i believe share our same goals, i expect. >> i'm seeing a lot of opportunity as well. you mentioned other cca's that currently exist but there are also many in the making as well. so these are all places or people who are working on these to be able to be part of the effort to get the rules we want. okay, i think we have no more questions on this part of this

. >> no problem thank you it's nice to be here this evening so barbara hale assistant general manager. we worked as mr. fried mentioned we worked in collaboration with enernex and lafco to prepare the report that enernex put before the agencies and there's five key points i want to emphasize from a business perspective. first setting the energy price and figuring out the mix of supply you can afford and mr. syphers made the same comment. phased implementation is smart with a two-tiered offering include light green and price -- the basic first tier light green type of offering at pg&e rates include build out out with expansion of the program and finally it may impact rates. it's sort of a tension that we all have to keep an eye on. the study was very helpful to us. i think we have good strong policy alignment now which was something missing prior to the study effort. we've also, while that study was underway and collaborating on it, we've also been doing our own business planning effort at the at the at the puc that business plan outlines our business opportunities including community

. >> barbara hale general manager formal power it is common practice within the city. >> what it attempted to address one thing great set of payers they're two setsz of payers the multiple and the klein power sf payers have separate revenue streams and make sure we separately accounted for them thank you. >> yes. jason fried. >> jason fried the staff fully supports moving forward we understand that the trick or treat should our we use the cca program is a stand alone program and getting a great rate i'd like to borrow off that recite it is so, please do an amazing rated i urge you encourage you to move forward with that rate and it's a wonderful rate .8 something any other comments? i just have i'm going to vote for this i do not like the idea ever this slump but want the program off and running all in favor, say i. >> i. >> opposed? the motion carries north america please. item 14 working group in your opinion for the power business plan. >> finally wow. so commissioners were we pleased to present to you today, the first of two workshops that did you say discuss our power proposed busines

. >> so the next just want acca cca barbara hale. >> assist general manager for power i have before you my two weeks update with the cca included in your packet i want to put it on the overhead projector it is the same charter you've seen at each meeting and i wanted to highlight that we have completed the presentation of the program design guidelines it the commission lecturer and presented to the rate fairness board they approved those rates method for setting the not to

. >> as barbara hill comes up i want to say a couple of things you'll hear a couple of themes one is it needs to be affordable we have very focused on affordability program a making sure that everyone can afford the power we're providing and when we perspire power on the open market we want to purchase it in california like commissioner courtney said it creates jobs in california they stay in california we're working on that there is legislation we'll proposed to streamline the process and then two product options you talk about light and dark green but two product options as we go forward how we mark those product options i am sorry to ms. hail and she'll continue with the presentation. >> thank you barbara hail for power i'll be coming up to make an update today's update is a little bit longer than than most we're present the policy program design for the program other of the updates i expect will be part of general manager report so looking at 9 slides you'll see we have an agenda of items to go through and the emphasis being what our program design is with the policies we're oper

. >> for barbara. >> all the information your collecting on the dark green can you get information on the question of opt up versus opt in and whether it is more strategic to do an opt up program than an opt into the higher program. >> oh, barbara hale i'll explore that issue i want to be clear the state of california cca program is an opt out. >> i'm talking about for that the dark green. >> we can't includes between the two but. >> but the opt in. >> yeah. opt up and opt in is the same either way the state requires a customer to be allowed to opt out of the program opt out is the nature of the program program. >> for - that's for the default product. >> i'm saying that is dark green is the opt out it is the big revenue generate our in mile-an-hour run for a dark green i losses some of the light green customers they say oh, my gosh i want to be in other program so be sure to opt into the dark green or strategic go after the people that are already enrolled they care about the program and target those people straeven and say we have a better product for you does that make sense. >> we

are complicated projects i couldn't do it doug made it sound easy this team a fantastic sharon and barbara and jennifer they're tough negotiators i'm surprised they let me have 38 my shirt this project is a multiple number of investors so silicon valley bank and wells fargo bank of the west and city national are you'll people that gave us money so from my prospective this is special thank you and we appreciate it (clapping) >> so supervisor kim was mentioning to see me that's the great point so some seniors that live and be part of the community are living in this home will have been the advocates for change i think that supervisor mentioned the incredible advocacy around the corner liquor dell lists we call them that in jerseys and all the wonderful thanks that happy and mercy is in an england visible position there's so much work but in addition to st. anthony's i want to thank the community partners that have been here and will continue to be here and do such great work lukter and he others (calling names) so thanks to everyone that do all the work that helped us get to here today lp (c

it was last year or two years a we started the office with barbara carlson who's here who just spoke, this meeting is coming full sickle that we were going to create this advisory circle of members who will be providing this kind of input on how we can have the finest network and coordination of early child care education services ins the kuntd ri that's going to happen in san francisco based on your work, so congratulations in getting us this far, now' eel go through the difficult decision of who's going to serve on the advisory committee. supervisor tang? >> thank you all so much to all the applicant, combined and collectively, you bring so much experience to the table, it's just amazing and even if you're not appointed to this committee, you will continue to do everything you can in your very fields and jobs to provide for our community, so with that said, i agree with supervisor avalos, you know, no issues with the mayoral appointees for item 8, i think those were fine and wonderful. item 7, i know that we have seat 6, 7, 8 and 9 up and we had several people who withdrew their app

we have been working very closely with barbara hale and her team over at puc over how the timing of this might roll out. there's a lot going on with respect to the launch of cca and in parallel with that we'll be working with michael and with barbara to anticipate what we need to do at the cpuc to get permission to launch our own independent energy efficiency programming. i don't don't know when that final result with the cpuc will be finished. however, it may not coincide directly with launch. but what will happen at launch is we will continue the current programs that we already have, so there will not be a break in service, but the actual launch of the new cca informed energy efficiency, the timing on that is a little bit questionable. we don't know exactly how long that will take. we're looking very carefully at the experience of sonoma and marin as they are involved with a similar request with the puc it's going to be very important that san francisco stay engaged with the puc for us to overcome some of these regulatory barriers by the iou's, by the utilities, we need to demonstrate

. >> santa barbara shall comes in and helps us show us things and this is one the owners they help us to socialize and i've been here about a year. >> we want to be sure to serve as many as we can. >> the san francisco cooking school is an amazing amazing partner. >> it is doing that in that space really elevates the space for the kids special for the chief that make it easy for them to come and it really makes the experience pretty special. >> i'm sutro sue set i'm a chief 2, 3, 4 san francisco. >> that's what those classes afford me the opportunity it breakdown the barriers and is this is not scary this is our choice about you many times this is a feel good what it is that you give them is an opportunity you have to make it seem like it's there for them for the taking show them it is their and they can do that. >> hi, i'm antonio the chief in san francisco. >> the majority of kids at that age in order to get them into food they need to see something simple and the evidence will show and easy to produce i want to make sure that people can do it with a bowl and spoon and burner and on

. >> santa barbara shall comes in and helps us show us things and this is one the owners they help us to socialize and i've been here about a year. >> we want to be sure to serve as many as we can. >> the san francisco cooking school is a

residents and the resident leadership and you know the tenants association tenant by labelle and shaw and barbara kohlman and others (clapping) you know great people (laughter) ada drain a they not only live in the development but hoped to design and put it together they put their blood and sweat search warrant us making sure we have build and design fits their needs and also adds to the fabric of this community i want to thank our partnerships san francisco housing division and the tabernacle association and my old friend reverend walker we've known each other and fred black and brown alliance is here and rich is here with enterprise and community development enterprise community partners and their help with hope sf and strategy are here working with the residents i got everyone needs to know that this is this development we're talking about takes millions and millions of dollars to do and it take people from the private sector to invest in community like this where most people are run away but j.p. morgan chase is here we've done hundreds of millions of with them and rb c, cc r.c. appreciate th

>> barbara hale that's our hope we will know after we go out to bid and see what the market is offering us if we can achieve that but that's absolutely where we want to be you know leading with affordability is the objective for that part of the program that competes with pg&e's default service. >> what is the mix of different energy sources that we're looking at com procter at at com to misnomer. to sonoma. >> they can go in sonoma because they have the geysers and we don't have that in san francisco i think the light green yes and the deep green -- there might have to be some outside because we don't have enough at a reasonable rate to be able to produce it here in san francisco that part might be slightly different if i'm not mistaken. >> so as we bring our program design to our commission, part of what we're talking about here is what's local embedded in what we're talking about sonoma is in a different position than us in terms of locally within the county's foot print so how we define local and whether it's the regional picture or san francisco specific you know, that will be part

realize that 21st century has 21st century opportunity to eliminate themanual and the scraping the barbara and the killing that technology give us the capacity if you choose to use it to watch every vehicle on the streets to witness all traffic actions and finally to hold outline violators at all levels of violation who is winning this conflict stopping your vision zero your vision of zero death from becoming real it looks like the score is to vision zero in the playoffs and in the big game it is death one vision zero thank you breed. >> you thank you very much. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> hi and doug i've been a driver guide since 1992 in san francisco and i'm here fighting for my job i agree the traffic safety is paramount and i think that people in my profession actually are some of the safety drivers out there i feel also when we talk about human impact we need to talk about the human impact on the variety of people in the tourism industry what it means to be a tougher guide in san francisco. >> sir, i'm sorry you're speaking about an item on the agenda and unfortunately you

project it is one of several that compromise the sfmta water system improvement project or w s i p as barbara the project manager for this project should the commission wish the colleague will present a brief description of the project elements for the proposed project otherwise we can skip to other comments okay now i'd like to state this is a hearing to receive the environmental impact report comments which assesses the commitment from the result of implementation from the west side cycle water project this was delivered to you staff is not here to respond to comments on the environmental analysis they'll be transcribed and in writing and responses to documents which will respond during the public comment period and may include provisions to the draft eir this is not for approval or disapproval of the project that will be held in the financial eir meeting comments if the public should be directed i directed towards the accuracy and commensurate are asked to speak slowly

businesses include the mary manicure and shops and library a real estate office insurance office arrest barbara shop and cleaners their plan to roommate the building is what that location has needed for years and years as it's been vacant and blight to the neighborhood and this 4 block business strict i have attended meetings with the earth and neighbors and the plan for the use is an excellent with an one and an excellent edition to the block lester and his wife have done everything to consider the needs of the neighborhood lester and karen have been devoted of the whole entire potrero hill at the come to the need and provided jobs to many including the young people they mentored and helped get into college this new business at 1512 20th student it should be commercially zoned for 25 years i support their plans and have no objections whatsoever to this project i ask you approve that immediately thank you. >> hello, i'm melinda a real estate agent on coastal with coldwell banker i recommended karen and lester when we purchased this on 20th street that happens that was a probate purchase it mean

i'm barbara first of all thank you for the opportunity to speak a year and a half i lost my job and am in school and working and starting a business this income is critical i've deeply concerned about the proposed amendment to remove the against distinctions within a host and non-host i submitted an application on the existing law and spent over $400 i'm still waiting for my permit i feel the city is betrayed that undermines the spirit of law the path and non-hosted in my view can be under stress we're not giving the law a chance to work anyone that hosts more than one hundred and 20 is someone like might have that needs the income i can't understand why the city imposed pain it is not - there's plenty the tax laws i can't understand why the city thinks to have a invasion of privacy and invite people to spy on each other my folks were in world war ii and they saw people pitted against each other in san francisco asked to report on families in their short-term rental is a violation of our rights please consider the situation as people like myself thank you (clapping.) >> hi 5 years ago

. >> barbara you practice on our speed. >> (inaudible) arrest depending on the questions. >> we're going to pause. >> i'm sorry. >> the next session will have the power? if it's going to take 24 minutes >> we want you fresh because a lot of information to - >> actually, that's probably a low estimate. >> about 45 minutes. >> yeah. >> so let's do this let's take a 10 minute break right now. >> sorry. >> oh i thought i asked for that. >> $10 $10, $10 i'm collecting. >> someone is going to be rich. >> do i have any public comment? >> ifblg brooks i'm with the i run the our city san francisco and the sustainability chair for the san francisco party on the water committee of the san francisco chapter of sierra club i'm not speaking officially, however, open the sierra club simply that is off-the-cuff we e it takes along for us to make speaking, however, i was at the water committee meeting last week where we had a long discussion about the drought and the regional water system and what we're being asked to do around the drought i want to put-down forwarding the concept that the people working

. >> so the next just want acca cca barbara hale. >> assist general manager for power i have before you my two weeks update with the cca included in your packet i want to put it on the overhead projector it is the same charter you've seen at each meeting and i wanted to highlight that we have completed the presentation of the program design guidelines it the commission lecturer and presented to the rate fairness board they approved those rates method for setting the not to exceed rates it is moving forward we're positions on may telephone to come to you with the rate proposal and program design description noement we're also looking forward to the board of supervisors having the first hearing on the procurement ordinance date has not been set to my knowledge but the first week in may we should have something to report on that at our next commission month to month i'm available to answer any questions we're on target thank you. >> questions. >> thank you mrs. hale i have a number of speakers on this item. >> jason. >> jason fried i think they did a good job the one thing for the quick up

. >> good afternoon, commissioners barbara hale general manager for energy i have 3 things to report on personnel and legislation reforms and sneak peak on the next activities first off happy to announce we're placing michael in our position of acting director of the program yeah. michael is here (clapping) >> michael has been with the cac program back when i first came to the puc he went off and learned more working in new york for the port authority and has come back to us been part of our regulatory and legislative team and directing it and stepping into the role of the actressing director thank you to him for joining us in that effort for leading us in that effort at the staff level the next item on prevention active reform we have i told you we need to have changes in the way we contract so we can perform our work exceedingly for our overhead procurement program we're moving forward towards

commission and the building inspection and the planning commission then ben is here who owns several barbara's bars in the city september up a petition in the city with 3 seven hundred signatures thank you for your sport in this legislation and today, i think we're joined by a few of the supporters as well thank you to the staff of the entertainment commission katie blackstone and our incredible city attorney vicky and ben welcome to the people's palace and director heinecke sanchez. >> to you for putting and continuing to take leadership on bringing this night time legislation to where we are and my colleagues thank you for hearing us at this time i want to bring forward bryan the president of the entertainment commission to talk about this legislation then we're going to call on diego sanchez when the planning department and then we're going to happy to answer questions and finally open up for public comment all right. madam president before we get to presentations scott wiener has a few items. >> thank you very much madam president and thank you supervisor breed for bringing this forward it